ARA San Juan: 34 families seek maximum penalty for four ex-naval chiefs

Nearly nine years after the ARA San Juan submarine imploded in the South Atlantic with its 44 crew members, the families of the victims are demanding significant prison sentences for four former naval officers. Lawyers representing 34 families requested five years of effective prison time and a ten-year disqualification from public office for each of the accused. Another lawyer sought even harsher penalties, up to seven or eight years.

The accused naval officers are former Vice Admiral Luis Enrique López Mazzeo, former Captain Claudio Javier Villamide, former Captain Héctor Aníbal Alonso, and former Lieutenant Commander Hugo Miguel Correa. The prosecution has charged them with aggravated culpable disaster resulting in death, combined with a breach of public official duties. However, the presiding judge noted that the prosecutors' requests are supplementary to the Public Prosecutor's Office, potentially limiting the impact of the families' specific demands.

During the proceedings, the defense attorneys presented a powerful closing argument, combining factual evidence with emotional appeals. One lawyer described the event as a "Chronicle of a death foretold," reconstructing the submarine's final hours. The narrative depicted the crew fighting for at least 20 hours inside the vessel amidst a storm, struggling with smoke, poor visibility, attempting to bail water, and trying to communicate, painting a grim picture of their final moments.

“

The first blow against a wall of the corridor. Another blow against the other. A headbutt against the pipe. I can't see because the smoke is preventing me.