Argentina's bid to scrap fixed book prices sparks industry fears

Argentina's government is once again attempting to repeal a law that mandates a single, fixed price for books, a move that has alarmed the country's publishing and bookselling industries. This initiative, part of a broader economic deregulation package, was previously proposed after President Javier Milei took office in 2023.

The current law, established in 2001, prevents individual bookstores, chains, or online platforms from setting their own prices for the same title or offering unrestricted discounts. The Ministry of Deregulation and State Transformation argues that eliminating this fixed-price system will foster competition among retailers, ultimately leading to lower prices for consumers. Minister Federico Sturzenegger is reportedly the architect of this proposal.

“

It is a project that is being worked on and is not yet defined in all its details. Its objective is for books to be more accessible to readers. To achieve this, it eliminates a restriction that currently prevents bookstores from competing on prices through discounts, promotions, or other commercial strategies. The premise is simple: when there is more competition, consumers have more options and better prices. International experience supports this approach. In the United Kingdom, after eliminating the fixed price system in 1995, not only did bookstores and book publishing disappear, but the number of published titles increased. There is no evidence in the world that a fixed price is necessary to preserve bibliodiversity.

Government officials state that the reform aims to make books more accessible by removing price restrictions. They contend that increased competition benefits consumers with more choices and better prices. The ministry points to the United Kingdom's experience after it abolished its fixed-price book system in 1995, claiming that book production and publishing did not suffer and the number of published titles even increased. They assert there is no global evidence that fixed prices are necessary to preserve bibliodiversity.

However, sector representatives express significant concern. They fear that removing price controls could lead to aggressive discounting by larger players, potentially driving smaller, independent bookstores out of business. Despite the ministry's assurances that the reform targets only price competition and not the existence of publishers or bookstores, the potential consequences for cultural diversity and the independent book market remain a major point of contention.

“

It should be clarified that the reform being worked on does not eliminate publishers, bookstores, copyrights, or cultural policies. What it eliminates is a prohibition on competing on prices. The objective is for more people to access books, expanding the offer for readers and allowing each bookstore to compete with the tools it deems most convenient.