Asbestos-tainted toys and e-commerce platforms' responsibility

Children's toys sold on major e-commerce platforms have been found to contain asbestos, raising serious concerns about consumer safety and the oversight of online marketplaces. Two Montessori-style sand drawing kits, designed to help children develop fine motor skills, were identified as containing tremolite, a naturally occurring form of asbestos.

Consumer watchdog Which? discovered tremolite asbestos in the sand of one kit sold on Amazon Marketplace and TikTok Shop. Exposure to asbestos can lead to severe lung diseases, even at low levels, and the International Agency for Research on Cancer classifies all forms of asbestos as human carcinogens. In the UK, any product containing even trace amounts of asbestos is banned.

A second kit, also purchased from TikTok Shop and listed by three independent retailers on Amazon Marketplace, revealed an even more alarming issue. This product had been subject to a recall order by the Office for Product Safety and Standards in March 2026 due to asbestos contamination, yet it remained available for purchase on both platforms until May 2026. This suggests a systemic disregard for safety regulations rather than a mere oversight.

“

The platforms seem accustomed to operating as 'neutral' markets, where legal responsibility is so dispersed that no one is truly accountable.

This incident is not isolated. Since November 2025, nearly 40 recall notices have been issued for asbestos-contaminated sand products, leading to the closure of schools and parks, most recently in Northeast England. The sand is typically sourced from mines in China where asbestos is naturally present. While this explains the origin, it does not absolve distributors of responsibility for quality control, especially for products intended for children.

E-commerce platforms often operate as "neutral" marketplaces, diffusing legal responsibility to the point where no single entity feels accountable. Amazon stated it is removing related product listings and investigating, while eBay reported quick action on identified items and ongoing reviews. TikTok confirmed the product was removed. However, these responses are reactive, not preventative. The UK government has proposed "duty of care" requirements for platforms to identify and remove dangerous products, but these proposals are still under consideration. Consumer groups warn that current regulations are too lax, leaving consumers at risk daily.

“

These reactions are essentially damage control, not preventative measures.