Attorney-general asks High Court to block PID appointments until after October elections

Israel's Attorney-General Gali Baharav-Miara has asked the High Court of Justice to halt government appointments to the Police Investigations Department (PID) until after the October 27 election. She argues that Justice Minister Yariv Levin wields too much influence over the selection process for key leadership roles.

The court is currently considering petitions against a new law that moved PID from the State Attorney’s Office to be more directly under the Justice Ministry. The appointments in question are for the director of the restructured department, a six-year term, and a senior official to resolve investigation disputes, a three-year term.

Baharav-Miara contends that appointing these officials shortly before an election would allow the current government to shape the leadership of a sensitive law-enforcement body for years. She also warned that the perception of political control over PID could deter police officers and prosecutors, especially during an election period when police are responsible for public order and managing demonstrations.

At the heart of the dispute is the five-member selection committee. Baharav-Miara claims Levin or his office significantly influences three of the committee members. The Justice Ministry director-general, appointed by Levin, chairs the committee. Levin also influenced the appointment of a criminal-defense lawyer and a third member, who was formally appointed by the Civil Service commissioner but whose selection was heavily guided by Levin's office. This influence is particularly concerning as the committee could potentially operate with only three members and has the power to dismiss the officials it appoints.