Ben-Gurion Airport strike: More porters, fewer passengers – what caused the crisis?

A recent wildcat strike at Ben Gurion Airport has intensified the conflict between the Israel Airports Authority (IAA) management and its workers' union, with staffing levels at the heart of the dispute. The union, led by Chairman Pinchas Idan, asserts a critical deficit of approximately 500 employees across all departments. Idan claims there are insufficient porters to manage luggage, forcing staff into grueling, consecutive 12-hour shifts under extreme heat and inhumane conditions, a situation exacerbated by employees serving in active military reserve duty.

However, data obtained by Walla presents a contrasting narrative. Comparing August 2019, a peak passenger year, with projections for August 2026, the number of porters has actually grown from 386 to 402. This increase of 16 porters occurred while overall passenger traffic is expected to decline by roughly 130,000. This suggests that the number of staff has not only kept pace but exceeded the operational needs based on passenger volume.

“

A union always wants more workers, and that's fine. But in this case, there is no shortage of porters because there are actually more of them. Besides, operational needs on the ground are no justification for shutting down a country.

Further complicating the union's stance, a source familiar with the matter revealed that the union never formally submitted a written request to management regarding a worker shortage. While acknowledging that unions often seek more staff, this source questioned the validity of the shortage claim, stating, "In this case, there is no shortage of porters because there are actually more of them." The source also criticized the union's actions, adding, "operational needs on the ground are no justification for shutting down a country."

Another perspective suggests the root of the problem lies not in the total number of employees but in the ratio of tenured to temporary staff. According to this view, a higher proportion of temporary workers in 2019 led to less burnout and greater flexibility. The shift towards more tenured staff over the years has resulted in a less motivated and flexible workforce. This source advocates for an operational overhaul, executed in cooperation with the union, to address the imbalance between tenured and temporary positions.

“

I claimed there are simply not enough porters to handle luggage loading and unloading, forcing staff into grueling, consecutive 12-hour shifts in unbearable heat under inhumane conditions.