Bishop Matthieu Rougé: 'Christian Healthcare Facilities May Have to Close or Leave France'

Bishop Matthieu Rougé of Nanterre has strongly criticized the French National Assembly's decision to exclude a conscience clause for private healthcare facilities concerning end-of-life care. The recently passed legislation will not allow these institutions to refuse the practice of assisted dying within their premises.

"Ideological fanaticism" is how Bishop Rougé described the government's stance. He highlighted that numerous healthcare providers, including palliative care homes and specialized care facilities, whether faith-based or not, had sought the right to refrain from performing euthanasia or assisted suicide. These institutions wished to uphold their ethical charters and traditions, which they believe are integral to the care they provide.

Bishop Rougé pointed to Socialist deputy Dominique Potier's suggestion of a similar derogation existing within the legal framework of the social and solidarity economy as proof that such a status is possible under French law. He stated that the government had previously offered assurances regarding this matter.

The bishop's warning suggests that Christian healthcare establishments might face a difficult choice: either cease their operations in France or close down entirely if they are compelled to participate in practices that conflict with their core beliefs and ethical commitments.