Can Canada uphold dairy supply management while giving U.S. more access?

As Canada and the U.S. move closer to a trade agreement, a significant point of contention remains: how Canada will reconcile its dairy supply management system with American demands for greater market access. The U.S. has long argued that Canada's system, which imposes high tariffs on exports exceeding certain quotas, severely limits access for American dairy products. U.S. President Donald Trump asserted this week that Canada had agreed to reduce tariffs on American farmers "down to zero." However, details were scarce. In contrast, Canadian Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc indicated that the supply management system itself would be preserved. "The prime minister was very clear: we needed to protect supply management, we needed to ensure that the supply management regime remained entirely intact, and I’m confident that that’s the case," LeBlanc told reporters. The looming threat of 50% tariffs on Canadian goods, which the White House had linked to perceived "discrimination" against U.S. dairy commerce, was temporarily paused for three days as negotiations entered their final stages. This pause provided a window for resolving the dairy dispute. Despite the U.S. dairy industry's stated issue not being with supply management per se, but rather with its implementation, they accuse Canada of employing tactics to keep American products out. Jamie Castaneda, executive vice-president at the U.S. National Milk Producers Federation, stated, "The U.S. dairy industry has never been after supply management. It’s become even more difficult [for exporters because] the Canadian government has decided to play even more games." Under the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement on free trade (CUSMA), the U.S. gained increased access to Canada's dairy market through tariff-rate quotas. However, the Trump administration and U.S. dairy groups allege that Canada exploits a legal loophole by allocating most of these quotas to processors rather than distributors or retailers, thereby continuing to restrict market entry for American dairy products.

“

The tariffs will be non-existent for our farmers. Our farmers were paying tremendous tariffs into Canada, and those tariffs are going to be totally eviscerated.