Can God be Mother? Debate grows over the feminine divine in monotheism

A provocative question is gaining traction in academic and spiritual circles: Why can't God the Father also be God the Mother? This inquiry challenges the predominantly male image of the divine in monotheistic religions and explores the historical and theological reasons behind the perceived absence of a feminine divine counterpart.

Thirty years ago, a creative advertisement for a women's magazine in Argentina playfully suggested, "We asked God to illuminate us to create the best magazine for women. And She listened." What was then a marketing ploy has become a reflection of a growing global conversation. Universities like Harvard, Princeton, Oxford, Cambridge, and the University of Buenos Aires are hosting dialogues among historians, theologians, and spiritual seekers about the feminine face of God.

“

We are living in the time of the 'death of God,' marked by social unrest, confusion, conflict, and fear… Perhaps it is not God who is dying, but rather the image we have projected onto Him.

The core of the debate lies in understanding why traces of the "Great Mother" from primitive cultures and the powerful goddesses of ancient mythologies seem to have vanished from the monotheistic worldview that emerged in the Middle East 4,000 years ago. In Greek mythology, for instance, Zeus reigned alongside goddesses like Hera, Athena, Artemis, Aphrodite, Demeter, and Hestia. The Hebrew theology of a singular, masculine, and omnipotent God, which influenced Christianity and Islam, established a patriarchal order. This shift not only removed goddesses from the sacred pantheon but also, according to some scholars, led to the subjugation of women on Earth, with Eve being blamed for original sin.

Many biblical scholars argue that this patriarchal structure was not a divine decree but a social and political construct of ancient elites. English historian Anne Baring, educated at Oxford and Sheffield, posits in her book "The Forgotten Feminine Face of God" that humanity is experiencing the "death of God," which might actually be the death of the male-centric image of the divine. She contends that fixing the image of divinity solely in the masculine gender has prevented a full understanding of the divine, impacting both individual spiritual balance and the equilibrium of civilization. Baring suggests that human consciousness has evolved through distinct stages, with an earlier "lunar phase" in the Paleolithic and Neolithic periods potentially reflecting a greater integration of feminine divine principles.

“

We have fixed the image of divinity in the masculine gender, refusing until very recently to consider that the feminine aspect of the spirit is essential for the fullness and balance of our image of the divine and, therefore, for the balance of civilization.