DistantNews
Support us
🇰🇷 South Korea /Culture & Society

Complicity in violence... 'No love without responsibility' [.txt]

From Hankyoreh · () Korean

Translated from Korean, summarized and contextualized by DistantNews.

At a glance

Analysis Sources not specified Context piece
  • A book review criticizes societal complicity in perpetuating violence within intimate relationships.
  • It highlights how victims are often blamed, while societal structures like media, law enforcement, and romanticized notions of relationships fail to provide adequate support.
  • The review discusses Nadine Macaluso's book, which reframes narratives of abuse and emphasizes accountability in love and relationships.

A recent book review, "Complicity in Violence... 'No Love Without Responsibility,'" scrutinizes the societal structures that enable and perpetuate violence within intimate relationships. The review highlights the common tendency to blame victims, citing a scene where a counselor admonishes a client, "You contributed to that violence!" This framing, often seen in media, forces victims to internalize blame for the abuse they endure, suggesting their choices led to their suffering.

You contributed to that violence!

— CounselorAccusing a client who has suffered abuse, reflecting a common societal tendency to blame victims.

The review argues that intimate partner violence is nurtured by a "social soil" that includes not only individual perpetrators but also a complicit society. This complicity manifests in various ways: counselors who blame victims, societal judgment towards those who remain in abusive relationships, insufficient police intervention, and a culture that romanticizes heterosexual relationships and upholds patriarchal norms. Despite this pervasive societal failure, the burden of guilt often falls solely on the victim.

Violence never victim's fault.

— Nadine MacalusoA core message from her book, challenging the narrative that victims are responsible for the violence they experience.

The review introduces Nadine Macaluso's book, "Love as Domination," which challenges this narrative. Macaluso recounts her own experience of being trapped in an abusive relationship for eight years, only escaping when police intervened. Her abuser's crimes were not initially recognized as violence but as financial misconduct. Following his release, he capitalized on his story, which was later adapted into the globally successful film "The Wolf of Wall Street." The review notes the irony that while the perpetrator's narrative was celebrated, the woman who suffered alongside him remained largely invisible.

Intimate relationship violence grows in social soil.

— Nadine MacalusoExplaining that societal factors contribute to the prevalence of domestic abuse.

Macaluso's book aims to ensure that no one else is erased as she was. Drawing on her trauma and survival, she confronts the societal tendency to shift responsibility onto victims. The review praises her work for offering a "different story" of love in a world that pressures individuals into relationships without accountability. Macaluso critiques counselors and media who attribute even the perpetrator's violence to the victim's actions, and she advocates for a middle ground that respects boundaries, rather than presenting only isolation or entanglement as options. The review concludes by emphasizing the book's core message: "There is no love without responsibility." While acknowledging that healing is a process, Macaluso offers a powerful voice to those who have been hurt, asserting their right to better support and recovery.

There is no love without responsibility.

— Nadine MacalusoA central theme of her book, emphasizing the need for accountability in relationships.
DistantNews Editorial

Originally published by Hankyoreh in Korean. Translated, summarized, and contextualized by our editorial team with added local perspective. Read our editorial standards.

More Stories

From Our Blog