DistantNews
Support us
🇮🇱 Israel /Culture & Society

Does Ben-Gvir’s flotilla stunt make him Israel’s anti-Zionist of the year?

From Jerusalem Post · () English

Translated from English and summarized by DistantNews. Read the original for the full story.

At a glance

Opinion Sources not specified Context piece
  • National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir is nominated for Israel's anti-Zionist of the year due to his actions, including humiliating flotilla prisoners and insulting President Isaac Herzog.
  • While criticizing Ben-Gvir's behavior, the author also acknowledges his positive contributions, such as rolling back prison indulgences for terrorists and making gun licenses more accessible.
  • The article argues that Zionism's foundational ideals, emphasizing moral restraint and avoiding humiliation even in conflict, are crucial for defending both the homeland and Israel's soul.

National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir is a contender for Israel's "anti-Zionist of the year" award, according to opinion writer Gil Troy. Ben-Gvir's actions, including a video humiliating flotilla prisoners and an insult directed at President Isaac Herzog, are cited as key criteria for this dubious distinction. Troy argues these actions violate Zionism's foundational ideals and Jewish values, damaging Israel's global standing and betraying supporters.

His video humiliating flotilla prisoners, giving them the kind of publicity they seek, followed by his insulting assault on President Isaac Herzog, met the key criteria for this mark of shame.

· Gil TroyThe author identifies Ben-Gvir's actions as reasons for his nomination for 'anti-Zionist of the year'.

Despite these criticisms, Troy acknowledges Ben-Gvir's positive contributions. He applauds the minister for reducing prison privileges for Palestinian terrorists and for expanding gun access to more Israelis, which he believes enhances safety and deters attackers. However, Troy deems Ben-Gvir's moral failings and public relations blunders inexcusable.

I applaud Ben-Gvir for rolling back some indulgences Palestinian terrorists enjoyed in prison, and for making gun licenses accessible to more Israelis, making Israel safer and deterring numerous terrorists.

· Gil TroyThe author acknowledges some of Ben-Gvir's policy achievements.

The article delves into the historical and ethical underpinnings of Zionism, referencing concepts like "purity of arms" coined by Berl Katznelson and the teachings of Yitzhak Sadeh. These principles advocate for moral restraint and avoiding humiliation of adversaries, even in times of conflict. The author stresses that maintaining humanity is essential, as a victory achieved through moral compromise would be hollow.

Facing brutal enemies, Zionists keep trying to fight effectively, aggressively, and creatively, but not viciously or vindictively.

· Gil TroyThe author contrasts effective defense with vindictive actions.

Troy connects these ideals to the IDF's code of ethics, Ruach Tzahal, which mandates soldiers to avoid harming enemies' lives, bodies, dignity, and property. He further links these principles to Torah law, citing Deuteronomy's limit on punishments to prevent degradation. The author concludes that mainstream religious Zionists uphold this balance, emphasizing that while punishment is legitimate, humiliation is not, and Israelis must defend their homeland without sinking to their enemies' level.

We must never sink to our enemies’ level, especially when we wield power and are not physically threatened.

· Gil TroyThe author emphasizes the importance of maintaining moral standards.
About this summary

Originally published by Jerusalem Post in English. Translated, summarized, and contextualized automatically by DistantNews, with a note on how the source frames the story. Not individually reviewed before publishing. How this works.

More Stories

From Our Blog