Dutch COVID-19 Handling Lacked Control Amidst Ministerial Disputes, Inquiry Reveals

The Dutch government's management of the COVID-19 pandemic, under the motto "Together we can control corona," appears to have been far from consistently controlled, according to the initial public hearings of a parliamentary inquiry. The first six weeks of testimony have exposed significant internal disagreements and a lack of unified action among ministers throughout the pandemic. Former Health Minister Hugo de Jonge recounted sharp disputes with then-Justice Minister Ferd Grapperhaus over vaccine prioritization in late 2020, with De Jonge ultimately refusing Grapperhaus's request to prioritize police officers. Despite such conflicts, De Jonge and Grapperhaus, along with Prime Minister Mark Rutte, often presented a united front against other cabinet members when formulating measures. For instance, D66 ministers Kajsa Ollongren and Wouter Koolmees opposed the introduction of a curfew, deeming it too restrictive of civil liberties. The decision to prioritize vaccinating the oldest citizens after healthcare workers reportedly caused "grumbling" among the economic ministers, Koolmees, Wopke Hoekstra, and Eric Wiebes, who favored vaccinating younger cohorts to accelerate the reopening of society. Education Minister Arie Slob expressed anger over De Jonge's push for a third school closure in late 2021. Former State Secretary Mona Keijzer criticized Rutte, De Jonge, and Grapperhaus, along with NCTV chief Pieter-Jaap Aalbersberg, for exhibiting "tunnel vision." She argued their singular focus on limiting hospital admissions overlooked other crucial societal interests. This criticism echoed sentiments from various quarters, suggesting that the priority given to preventing IC bed shortages often overshadowed concerns for the economy, education, and the mental health of young people. An official, Marina Eckenhausen, recalled advising De Jonge to involve behavioral scientists, economists, and social experts in policymaking, but her advice was reportedly not pursued. The Children's Ombudsman, Margrite Kalverboer, stated that children's well-being was not prioritized, and a student representative shared receiving "heartbreaking emails" about loneliness among students in the spring of 2021.

“

chagrijn