EU court questions some FIFA agent rules

The European Court of Justice has cast doubt on several FIFA regulations concerning football agents, deeming some incompatible with EU competition law and others potentially obstructing the free provision of services. The Luxembourg-based court's decision, prompted by a lawsuit from two player agents in Germany, addresses rules that limit agent remuneration, restrict simultaneous representation of multiple parties in a transfer, and govern licensing requirements.

Specifically, the ECJ found a rule prohibiting agents from contacting or signing a client already under an exclusive representation contract, except within a two-month window before its expiration, to be incompatible with European legislation against collusive practices. The court argued this rule grants an undue advantage to agents already bound by exclusive contracts, allowing them to renegotiate terms or sign new deals outside the specified period.

Regarding abuse of a dominant position, the ECJ acknowledged FIFA's dominant role in the international transfer market for professional players and coaches. However, it deferred to national courts the decision on whether specific rules constitute an abuse of this dominance and if such behavior can be justified. The court also indicated that certain regulations, including those on multiple representation, licensing, and agent "contacts," could impede the freedom to provide services. The extent to which these rules restrict this freedom, particularly if they deter agents from operating in other EU states, will also be assessed by national courts.

“

by which they are conferred an undue advantage