From my watchtower in Jerusalem, I am still watching New York

New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani's absence from the annual Israel Day Parade has drawn criticism, marking the first time in the event's history, since 1964, that a sitting mayor has not attended. The parade is a significant public celebration for the city's Jewish community, drawing over 100,000 participants.

From Jerusalem, author Shmuel Legesse observed the parade with mixed emotions, expressing pride in the turnout but disappointment in the mayor's decision. He contends that Mamdani's absence sends a message to Jewish New Yorkers, particularly during a period of rising antisemitism, suggesting a lack of solidarity.

Legesse emphasizes the distinction between criticizing Israeli government policies, which he acknowledges is legitimate, and refusing to stand with a community celebrating its identity. He argues that the parade is a celebration of the Jewish people and their homeland, not a referendum on the current Israeli administration.

"Leadership is not only about showing up for communities when it is politically convenient. Leadership is about showing up when it is politically difficult," Legesse writes. He suggests that Mamdani's supporters might cite disagreement with Israeli policies, but this misses the core meaning of the event for many in the Jewish community who are seeking reassurance and support from their elected officials.

“

Leadership is not only about showing up for communities when it is politically convenient. Leadership is about showing up when it is politically difficult.