HRCP flags inconsistencies in Lahore police custody deaths, urges tribunal

The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP) has identified significant discrepancies in the official narrative surrounding the deaths of two young women, Amina and Anmol, in police custody in Lahore. The women were detained on August 4 on theft allegations and died within two hours at the Township police station. Conflicting accounts have emerged regarding the timeline, their ages, and whether they were alive when taken to the hospital.

HRCP's fact-finding report highlights a stark contradiction between the family's account, which noted visible bruises and dried blood on the bodies, and official records stating no external injuries. The commission also questions the preliminary postmortem reports, which showed remarkably similar findings for both women. Further concerns were raised about the alleged absence of female police officers during detention, delays in informing the family, and the police's extensive control over the postmortem and burial processes.

While acknowledging a judicial inquiry, HRCP concluded that the case's inconsistencies necessitate a more credible and independent investigation. The commission urged the Punjab government to establish a judicial tribunal, led by a sitting judge of the Lahore High Court, with full powers to summon witnesses, examine evidence, and publish findings within a set timeframe. The tribunal would also be tasked with ordering independent forensic examinations, including potential exhumation, and verifying the official timeline. HRCP emphasized the need for immediate protection and legal aid for the victims' family, given their vulnerable socioeconomic status.