Irish family lawyers threaten legal aid withdrawal over pay and reform

Family lawyers in Ireland are poised to withdraw their legal aid services by the end of the month, citing a lack of engagement from the Department of Justice on pay and civil legal aid reform. This action could significantly disrupt family law cases, affecting vulnerable individuals seeking representation in matters of child maintenance, custody, guardianship, and domestic violence.

“

unless there is a “meaningful” response

The lawyers, represented by the family law legal aid private practitioners panel, have formally urged Justice Minister Jim O’Callaghan to address their concerns. Their demands align with recommendations from a civil legal aid reform group's reports last year. If the minister does not provide a "meaningful" response by the end of next week, the lawyers intend to stop taking on new cases, though they will continue to honor existing assignments.

“

Family lawyers say they have had no pay increase over 20 years.

This situation is distinct from the ongoing protest by criminal defense lawyers who are already withdrawing services over a new flat-fee model for criminal legal aid. The family lawyers argue they have not received a pay increase in two decades. They contend that the current flat fees, ranging from €339 to €508 per application, do not adequately compensate for the work involved, especially considering potential adjournments and the complexity of cases, including urgent domestic violence applications.

“

the private practitioner legal aid flat fee, ranging from €339 for a single application, such as for child maintenance or access, up to €508 for applications for several orders, including domestic violence, does not allow for adjournments or reflect the work and number of appearances involved.

Should family lawyers cease new case intake, the Legal Aid Board, already strained by high demand, would face immense pressure. It would need to reassign lawyers from other duties, potentially impacting other civil legal aid services, to cover family court proceedings. The lawyers' decision to escalate follows a meeting at Dublin's Dolphin House family court complex, where they agreed to send a letter demanding immediate engagement on their critical issues.

“

demanding “meaningful” engagement