Is it wise for a tourism-dependent country to restrict alcohol sales?

Croatian municipalities now possess the authority to prohibit the sale of spirits, beer, and wine in stores between 9 PM and 6 AM, a measure intended to safeguard public health, order, cultural heritage, and the environment. This new provision, part of amendments to the Trade Act, also prohibits the sale of energy drinks to individuals under 18.

“

Free to write that this is another law that harms us small traders. The state does not think of us.

The law has sparked divided opinions regarding its wisdom and enforceability, particularly for a nation heavily reliant on tourism. Critics argue it could be socially discriminatory, favoring those who can afford to dine and drink in restaurants, bars, and clubs over those who shop in convenience stores. Small business owners, especially kiosk operators, express concern that the ban will severely impact their already thin profit margins, as alcohol sales often constitute their primary income, particularly during evening hours.

“

If the desire is to reduce public intoxication on city streets and disturbances of peace and quiet, the ban could only be imposed on the city center.

Nikša Vrca, a craftsman from Split, voiced his frustration, calling it another law detrimental to small businesses. He suggested that if the goal is to reduce public intoxication, the ban should be limited to city centers rather than a blanket restriction. He believes tourists will simply find ways to purchase alcohol before the cutoff time, rendering the measure ineffective. Antonela Botić, who runs two kiosks outside Split's center, echoed these sentiments, stating that her businesses survive on alcohol sales and that a zone-based ban, targeting areas with known issues like the city center, would be more logical than a widespread restriction.

“

What does Mejaši have to do with the city center, where you find a hundred drunk guests?

Conversely, some individuals working in the tourism sector believe that stricter regulations are long overdue. They point to the uncontrolled behavior of some tourists, which they argue is degrading the city's atmosphere. The proliferation of ATMs, souvenir shops selling kitsch items, and establishments offering a wide range of goods, from beer to condoms, contributes to a chaotic environment, according to these perspectives. The debate highlights the tension between maintaining public order and supporting local businesses in Croatia's vital tourism industry.

“

It is high time to introduce order because the behavior of some tourists has gotten out of control.