DistantNews
Support us
๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡ฑ Israel /Elections & Politics

It's time for Israel to end Temple Mount appeasement for good - opinion

From Jerusalem Post · () English

Summarized and contextualized by DistantNews.

At a glance

Opinion Named sources Context piece
  • The author argues that Israel should end its policy of appeasement regarding the Temple Mount, citing personal experiences from 2009 and the recent Shavuot holiday.
  • In 2009, the author and his daughter were questioned by police for perceived provocative actions, such as swaying, while visiting the Temple Mount.
  • The author criticizes the Israeli government and police for surrendering to threats of Muslim violence and urges them to enforce public order rather than restrict civil rights.

The author contends that Israel must definitively cease its policy of appeasement concerning the Temple Mount, drawing on personal experiences spanning over 16 years. He recounts two visits with his daughter to the holy site: one in December 2009 and another on the recent Shavuot eve. These visits highlight what he describes as the Israeli government's gradual, yet insufficient, withdrawal from appeasing Arab terror and intolerance.

Was your daughter swaying?

โ€” Police OfficerQuestioning the author's daughter about her behavior on the Temple Mount.

During the 2009 visit, shortly before his daughter's wedding, both he and his daughter were subjected to police questioning. The author was specifically asked if his daughter had been swaying, an action the police deemed provocative and unlawful for a Jew on the Temple Mount. He was lectured that any body motion, gesture, or facial expression by Jews could potentially incite religious war with surrounding Muslim countries, illustrating the extent of the Israeli authorities' perceived capitulation to threats of Muslim violence.

You know... how that was quite obviously a provocative action and, therefore, an unlawful and improper movement for a Jew to make on the Temple Mount.

โ€” Police OfficerExplaining why swaying was considered a provocative action by Jews on the Temple Mount.

The author criticizes the Israeli government and police for prioritizing ease of their jobs over enforcing fundamental civil rights. He questions what actions would be taken if Jewish groups threatened violence to ban Muslim prayer at the al-Aqsa Mosque. He urges the authorities to abandon their fear-driven approach and uphold public order, rather than restricting basic rights. His daughter's distress at being detained and questioned the day before her wedding underscores the personal impact of these policies, leading him to believe that by the time her children marry, Jews will be able to pray freely on the Temple Mount.

It was extremely distressing to note the extent to which the Israeli government and police had abjectly surrendered to threats of Muslim violence.

โ€” David KirshenbaumExpressing his dismay at the perceived capitulation of Israeli authorities to threats.
DistantNews Editorial

Originally published by Jerusalem Post. Summarized and contextualized by our editorial team with added local perspective. Read our editorial standards.