Jacques Houdek Criticizes 'The Voice' Contestant's Performance, Advises Urgent Help; She Responds

A public exchange between singer Jacques Houdek and former "The Voice" contestant Duška Brčić Šušak has highlighted concerns over vocal health and artistic interpretation. Houdek offered a blunt assessment of Šušak's recent performance of Oliver Dragojević's song "Ostavljam te samu" at an event in Vela Luka.

“

Unfortunately... no! Duška is talented and her interpretation comes from a truly, it seems, sincere place, but the voice is unfortunately sick, this is a diagnosis on the vocal cords... Out of tune, hoarse (and no, not like Oliver, lest anyone dare to draw a parallel! Oliver sang exactly as he speaks). And this is simply wrong, the tone is distorted and ugly... aggressive... because it has to be, unfortunately, it doesn't come out any other way... Duška urgently, urgently must find help for her voice.

Posting on Instagram, Šušak shared her rendition, expressing her deep connection to the music and the event. However, Houdek commented that her performance was "out of tune" and her voice sounded "sick," suggesting a chronic issue with her vocal cords. He strongly advised her to "urgently, urgently find help for her voice," recalling that she had sounded hoarse even as a child.

Šušak responded directly to Houdek's critique, acknowledging his opinion but asserting that her vocal cords are healthy. She stated she had undergone a medical examination a few months prior that confirmed this. While respecting his perspective on her singing, she emphasized that her health is her top priority. Houdek later added another message, reiterating his belief in her musical talent and emotional delivery, but urging her to consider the technical aspects of her vocal production.

“

Dear Jacques, I was scared when I read the message, but I must say that I had an examination a few months ago and, fortunately, everything is fine with my vocal cords. Maybe you don't like how I sing, maybe you don't like this song or my way of singing in general, and I completely respect that. But as far as health is concerned, everything is fine, and that is the most important thing to me. Thank you very much!

The exchange has sparked discussion about the line between constructive criticism and public commentary on an artist's health, particularly within the competitive music industry.

“

The song is truly beautiful, your feeling for the text is there, unadulterated, that is unquestionable. You have something to say in music and I truly believe in you, your common sense and hearing that you have, to hear that this is not...