Knesset passes law placing internal police investigations under Justice Ministry's authority

Israel's Knesset has passed a contentious law placing the Police Internal Investigations Department (PIID) under the direct authority of the Justice Ministry, a move that severs its ties with the State Attorney's Office. The legislation, championed by Likud MK Moshe Saada, passed with a 43-39 vote after extensive debate.

The PIID, currently an independent body within the prosecution service, investigates alleged misconduct by police officers. Critics, however, express grave concerns that its new placement within the Justice Ministry could compromise the independence of investigators and prosecutors. Senior researchers from the Israel Democracy Institute have warned that the legislation might impair the PIID's professional effectiveness and erode public trust in law enforcement.

“

Today we are carrying out a reform. There will no longer be criminals serving with

The law designates the PIID as an "independent body within the Justice Ministry," empowering it to investigate and prosecute police officers for criminal offenses. The mechanism for appointing and dismissing the PIID's head has also been altered, with a five-member committee, largely composed of politically affiliated appointees, now responsible. The justice minister will hold significant control over this committee.

“

the legislation could impair the ability to operate professionally and effectively, and weaken public trust in law enforcement authorities.

Attorney-General Gali Baharav-Miara and State Attorney Amit Aisman had previously cautioned that the bill risked exposing investigations into police misconduct to political influence. They argued that the restructuring would create a parallel law enforcement authority outside the attorney-general's professional oversight, potentially leading to divergent enforcement standards and politically motivated priorities.

Supporters, including Saada, a former deputy head of the PIID, contend that institutional separation is crucial to resolve perceived conflicts of interest. They argue that prosecutors often rely on police investigators in criminal cases, creating a potential conflict with a unit tasked with investigating those same officers. The move also occurs amidst a strained relationship between the government and the attorney-general.

“

the legislation risks exposing investigations into police misconduct to political influence at a time of mounting strain within Israel’s law enforcement system.