Los Angeles: Franco-American suspect in deadly Pacific Palisades fire pleads not guilty again

Jonathan Rinderknecht, a 30-year-old Franco-American Uber driver, has once again pleaded not guilty to charges related to a deadly fire in Los Angeles. The blaze, which occurred on New Year's Eve 2025, devastated the upscale Pacific Palisades neighborhood and claimed the lives of 12 people.

“

The investigation has never provided scientific evidence establishing that he was the source of the fire.

Rinderknecht is awaiting his second trial, scheduled to begin on November 2. He remains in federal custody. His first trial concluded without a verdict, as the jury could not reach a consensus on his responsibility. Prosecutors had sought up to 45 years in prison for charges including arson.

Crucially, the investigation has not produced scientific evidence directly linking Rinderknecht to the fire's ignition. While his phone data indicated he was near the fire's starting point, and passengers described him as angry and alluding to vigilantism that night, his defense argued he was a "good Samaritan" who called for help. They also suggested fireworks might have started the blaze and accused the Los Angeles Fire Department of failing to contain the initial fire, thus becoming scapegoats.

“

The data from his phone showed that he was close to the starting point of the flames.

His defense attorney portrayed Rinderknecht as a scapegoat, intended to mask the fire department's alleged failure to extinguish the initial blaze. The prosecution's case appears to hinge on circumstantial evidence and witness accounts of his state of mind.

“

His lawyer also depicted him as a scapegoat used to mask the failure of the Los Angeles firefighters to extinguish the initial fire, pointing to their responsibility for the catastrophe.