Magistrate's Exit from Electoral Tribunal Sparks Concern Among INE Councilors

Concerns are rippling through Mexico's National Electoral Institute (INE) following the unexpected early departure of Magistrate Mónica Soto Fregoso from the Superior Chamber of the Federal Judicial Power's Electoral Tribunal (TEPJF). Her resignation comes less than a month before the 2026-2027 electoral process is set to commence, raising alarms among electoral councilors.

During a session on Tuesday, councilor Carla Humphrey lamented that Soto Fregoso's exit creates two vacancies that should be filled by women within the Superior Chamber. "Now Magistrate Claudia Valle is left alone, unfortunately there are two vacancies," Humphrey stated, questioning whether a replacement would be appointed or if the INE would include the positions in its next judicial election.

“

Now Magistrate Claudia Valle is left alone, unfortunately there are two vacancies.

Councilor Martín Faz echoed these concerns, emphasizing that while the presiding magistrate holds a tie-breaking vote, the absence of a full collegiate body weakens the tribunal's decision-making process. "A tie-breaking vote leads to the decision resting solely on the judgment of one person, which is precisely why collegiate bodies exist," Faz explained. He added that the tribunal's integration is crucial for its institutional architecture, designed to prevent decisions from being concentrated in a single individual.

Councilor Jorge Montaño suggested that legally, filling Soto's vacancy would likely need to wait for the next Judicial Power election, as an extraordinary election so close to the September 10 start of the process would be impractical. However, he noted that electoral tribunals possess their own substitution mechanisms, which could offer a solution.

“

A tie-breaking vote leads to the decision resting solely on the judgment of one person, which is precisely why collegiate bodies exist.