DistantNews
Support us
🇹🇼 Taiwan /Sports

Messi's World Cup Challenge Sparks FIFA Complaint After No Red Card Issued

From Liberty Times · () Chinese

Translated from Chinese, summarized and contextualized by DistantNews.

At a glance

News Named sources Context piece
  • Lionel Messi's dangerous leg stomp on Algeria's Aissa Mandi during a World Cup match, which did not result in a red card, has prompted Algeria's Football Federation to file a formal complaint with FIFA.
  • While some commentators believe Messi received preferential treatment, former Premier League referee Graham Scott suggested the action lacked clear malice or intensity, and the on-field reaction did not strongly indicate a foul.
  • Scott acknowledged that replays could make the decision more controversial, noting Messi was fortunate the VAR did not recommend a review, which might have led to a red card.

Lionel Messi's controversial moment in the World Cup group stage match against Algeria, where he stepped on opponent Aissa Mandi's calf without receiving a red card, has ignited a formal complaint from the Algerian Football Federation to FIFA. The incident occurred in the 32nd minute of the first half when Messi, while contesting for the ball, stepped on Mandi's leg from behind. Neither the on-field referee nor VAR intervened, a decision that drew sharp criticism from ESPN commentator Alejandro Moreno, who stated the action warranted a red card and suggested superstars often receive favorable treatment.

this action 100% warrants a red card

— Alejandro MorenoESPN commentator Alejandro Moreno's assessment of Messi's challenge.

The Algerian Football Federation has officially lodged a complaint with FIFA regarding the referee's decisions during the match. Sources familiar with the matter, who requested anonymity, revealed that the federation's primary grievances include Messi's studs directly hitting Mandi's calf and Achilles tendon, as well as two separate elbowing incidents. FIFA has been approached for comment but has not yet responded.

rarely would a referee send a player off for that action

— Graham ScottFormer Premier League referee Graham Scott's opinion on the incident.

However, referee expert and former Premier League official Graham Scott offered a different perspective. He argued that few referees would have sent Messi off for that particular action, not because of his superstar status, but due to a perceived lack of clear malice or intensity in the move. Scott also pointed out that the on-field reaction from Algerian players was relatively calm, suggesting they did not perceive it as a deliberate foul. This lack of strong protest from players can influence VAR decisions, as modern VAR systems are sometimes criticized for disrupting game flow and may not intervene if players themselves do not strongly react.

the action lacked clear malice or intensity

— Graham ScottFormer Premier League referee Graham Scott's analysis of Messi's challenge.

Despite this, Scott conceded that from a replay angle, the decision is more debatable. Messi's studs did connect with Mandi's calf, and Mandi's pained reaction was evident. He suggested that some VAR officials might have recommended the referee review the play on the monitor, indicating that Messi was somewhat fortunate in this instance.

if viewed from the replay angle, this decision is indeed more controversial

— Graham ScottFormer Premier League referee Graham Scott's view on the VAR decision.
DistantNews Editorial

Originally published by Liberty Times in Chinese. Translated, summarized, and contextualized by our editorial team with added local perspective. Read our editorial standards.

More Stories

From Our Blog