Meta meets its own 'tobacco' moment in court

Meta Platforms Inc. is set to defend itself in a U.S. trial this week against allegations that its social media applications are intentionally designed to foster addiction among young users. Experts are drawing parallels between this case and the "big tobacco moment" that social media is now facing, emphasizing the legal arguments centered on the company's business practices.

The trial, which begins with jury selection in Oakland, California, involves four states, California, Colorado, Kentucky, and New Jersey, that sued Meta in 2023. Prosecutors aim to prove that Meta deliberately engineered Facebook and Instagram to be addictive for children. A Meta spokesperson stated the company "strongly disagrees with these allegations" and is "confident the evidence will show our longstanding commitment to supporting young people," citing efforts to engage with parents and experts.

“

It really feels like tobacco in the 1990s.

Legal experts like Vincent Joralemon, director at Berkeley's Life Sciences Law and Policy Center, liken the current situation to the 1990s when tobacco companies faced intense scrutiny. Decades of research had established the health risks of tobacco, and subsequent investigations revealed how the industry allegedly concealed these harms. Similarly, the social media cases revolve around the intersection of technology, addiction, and mental health.

“

Meta 'strongly disagrees with these allegations' and is 'confident the evidence will show our longstanding commitment to supporting young people'.

In the 1990s, a landmark settlement saw tobacco companies face financial penalties and restrictions on marketing, particularly targeting children. Now, the states are demanding not only financial penalties potentially reaching $1.4 trillion, close to Meta's market value, but also a wide array of changes to Meta's apps. Meta has previously faced similar accusations, resulting in convictions and damages nearing $1 billion in separate trials.

Beyond the financial implications, experts highlight reputational damage and the potential for forced operational changes as Meta's most significant challenges. The trial's outcome could have profound implications for the social media industry's future practices and accountability.

“

The huge issue here is reputational harm and being forced to make major changes.