Milei Decrees Ban on Foreigners Expressing Hate Towards Argentina, Experts Warn of Discretion

Argentine President Javier Milei has enacted a decree modifying the Migration Law, effectively prohibiting the entry or ordering the expulsion of foreigners who express hate speech against Argentina. This measure, published late Wednesday, will remain in effect pending congressional review, but legal experts caution that it opens the door to significant discretionary power.

“

The decree is not clear and there is no certainty about how applicable it is.

The new regulation targets individuals who have "directed messages of hate in an oral or written form, or incited violence against the Argentine people as a whole, or against any Argentine citizen, motivated by the latter's nationality." It also includes sanctions for those who have "performed or participated in acts of desecration of national patriotic symbols" or incited such acts. However, legal experts like Lucía Galoppo from the Center for Legal and Social Studies (CELS) point out the decree's lack of clarity on what constitutes hate speech, how it will be detected, and the criteria for evaluation, leaving ample room for arbitrary state decisions.

“

All of that makes it difficult to apply and discretionary because it leaves too many gaps that the State could fill with arbitrary criteria.

The decree has drawn criticism from opposition sectors. Leonel Chiarella, president of the Radical Civic Union (UCR), deemed the presidential decree unconstitutional and called for its explicit rejection by Congress. Meanwhile, Peronist deputy Agustín Rossi argued that "under the guise of an anti-Argentine campaign," Milei is advancing his anti-immigrant agenda, drawing parallels to former U.S. President Donald Trump's immigration policies.

“

the president's DNU is unconstitutional

Argentina has historically been a nation welcoming to immigrants, offering equal rights in healthcare, education, and housing, alongside constitutionally protected civil rights. The new decree, which President Milei reportedly initiated after alleging an "anti-Argentine campaign" without presenting evidence, signals a departure from this tradition. Concerns have been voiced by immigrants like Felipe, a Colombian living in Buenos Aires since 2009, who expressed fear that the measure might escalate, stating, "I adore Argentina for all that it has given me and continues to give me."

“

under the guise of an anti-Argentine campaign, Javier Milei advances his policy against migrants