Money transferred to elder son before parent's death: Can it be reclaimed in South Korea? [Inheritance Report]

A family dispute has emerged following a father's death, centered on a significant sum of money transferred to his elder son's account just before the parent passed away. The remaining heirs discovered this discrepancy while organizing the deceased's finances, leading to questions about whether the funds were a gift or part of the inheritance.

“

Money transferred to a child's account before a parent's death is not automatically considered a gift or part of the inheritance.

Legal experts clarify that money transferred to a child's account before a parent's death isn't automatically classified as a gift or inheritance. The determination hinges on various factors, including the parent's mental capacity at the time of the transfer, their intentions, and how the funds were managed. If the parent was of sound mind and intended to gift the money, it's likely considered a gift. However, if the account was merely used for safekeeping or the parent's name was only lent, the funds could be treated as part of the estate to be inherited.

Courts consider multiple elements when evaluating such financial movements within families. These include the relationship between the parties, the amount involved, the purpose of the transaction, the timing and frequency of the transfers, and the overall method of financial management. If it's determined that one heir improperly took or used the parent's money, other heirs can claim it as a 'special benefit' during the inheritance division process. Legal actions like claims for unjust enrichment or damages are also possible, depending on the specifics of the fund's movement and use.

“

If the parent gave the money to the child while having normal judgment, it is likely to be recognized as a gift. On the other hand, if there are circumstances that suggest the name was merely borrowed or the money was simply entrusted for safekeeping, it can be judged as inheritance.

Crucial evidence in resolving these disputes includes objective documentation such as text messages, KakaoTalk conversations, recordings, and memos. Bank transaction records, proof of how the funds were actually used, and the pattern of significant money movement just before the parent's death are all vital. If an heir managed the parent's bank account, other heirs can request financial transaction details from the bank by proving their heir status. If a lawsuit is already underway, they can also petition the court to order the disclosure of financial information.

“

Text messages, KakaoTalk conversations, recordings, and memos, as well as bank transaction details, actual fund usage, and the circumstances of concentrated money movement just before death, can all be important judgment materials.

As South Korea's population ages, more families are seeing adult children manage their parents' assets, leading to an increase in inheritance disputes among siblings. To prevent such conflicts, it's important to clearly distinguish between managing funds and gifting them. Even when funds are used for living expenses or medical bills on behalf of the parent, keeping records through account transfer memos or text messages can help prevent future disputes. Documenting the purpose and settlement of funds is key when one sibling manages a parent's assets.

“

It is important to pre-determine the purpose and usage criteria for entrusted funds to avoid confusion between management and gifts. Even when using money on behalf of parents for living expenses or medical bills, leaving the purpose in account transfer memos or text messages can help prevent future inheritance disputes.