‘Not an investigation’: So why are Munster Rugby carrying out a root-and-branch review?

Munster Rugby is currently engaged in a comprehensive governance and organizational review, spearheaded by independent chairman Martin Kelleher. A press release issued on Monday sought to clarify the nature of this undertaking, describing it as a "forward-looking" process aimed at assessing whether the organization's governance, leadership, culture, engagement, communication, and operational arrangements are both appropriate and effective.

“

The board of Munster Rugby has commissioned the review to assess whether the organisation’s governance, leadership, culture, engagement and communication, organisational and operational arrangements are appropriate and effective.

The review has been commissioned by the board of Munster Rugby. However, the press release's assertion that the process is "not an investigation, a disciplinary process or a fault-finding exercise" has raised questions. Critics and observers wonder how the review can effectively identify and learn from past system failures or governance issues if it is not designed to look for historical precedent or expose flaws.

“

It is not an investigation, a disciplinary process or a fault-finding exercise, and it does not seek to attribute blame to individuals. Its purpose is to support learning and reform, to strengthen governance, accountability and decision making, and to position Munster Rugby for long-term sustainability.

The review is being conducted by The Governance Company, an independent consultancy specializing in corporate governance, led by David W Duffy. Kelleher and a board-appointed steering group report independently to the board. Kelleher himself is independent of Munster Rugby and has no conflicts of interest that could compromise objectivity. The conduct, methodology, evidence, and conclusions of the review are matters for the chair, steering group, and reviewer, not for Munster Rugby's executive or management.

“

The review is the responsibility of the independent chair, Martin Kelleher, and a board-appointed steering group. It is being conducted by The Governance Company, an independent consultancy specialising in corporate governance, led by David W Duffy. The chair and the steering group report independently to the board.

The process involves seeking views from key internal and external stakeholders, including playing and non-playing staff, and a broad range of individuals with a vested interest in Munster Rugby's governance. Engagement is being carried out through structured interviews, confidential surveys, and a review of documentation, benchmarked against good practice. Confidentiality is emphasized as a fundamental aspect of the process to encourage honest participation and preserve the integrity of the review, with individual contributions remaining undisclosed.

“

The views of key internal and external stakeholders are being sought. This includes playing and non-playing staff and a broad range of others with a direct interest in how Munster Rugby is governed and run.