Prince Harry, Elton John ordered to pay millions in failed lawsuit
Translated from English, summarized and contextualized by DistantNews.
At a glance
- Prince Harry, Elton John, and other claimants must pay millions in legal costs to the Daily Mail's publisher after a judge ruled their privacy lawsuits were conducted unreasonably.
- Judge Matthew Nicklin ordered an interim payment of ยฃ9.54 million towards Associated Newspapers' legal costs, with a further damaging ruling that these costs should be paid on an โindemnity basisโ.
- The ruling follows the dismissal of the claimants' case last month, which alleged unlawful activities by the Mail titles, including phone hacking.
Britainโs Prince Harry and other prominent figures, including singer Elton John, face a substantial financial penalty after a judge found their failed privacy lawsuits against the Daily Mailโs publisher were conducted unreasonably. Judge Matthew Nicklin ordered the claimants to pay an interim sum of ยฃ9.54 million towards Associated Newspapers' legal costs by August 28.
In my judgment, the cumulative effect โof these matters takes the case well outside the norm. The conduct was unreasonable to a high degree.
In a significant blow, Nicklin also ruled that the additional costs should be paid on an โindemnity basis.โ This means the publisher does not need to prove the costs were reasonable and proportionate, potentially increasing the final bill for the claimants. This decision comes after the judge comprehensively rejected the case last month, dismissing allegations of widespread unlawful activities by the Mail titles, such as phone hacking.
another overwhelming โvictory for the Mail and its journalism
Nicklin was critical of how the claimants presented their case, noting that serious allegations were based on โspeculative and inferentialโ foundations. He stated that the cumulative effect of these issues took the case โwell outside the normโ and that the conduct was โunreasonable to a high degree.โ A spokesperson for Associated Newspapers hailed the ruling as โanother overwhelming victory for the Mail and its journalism.โ
a complete and obvious whitewash
The judgment adds to Prince Harry's ongoing legal battles with the media. He previously won a case against the publisher of the Daily Mirror and settled a claim with Rupert Murdoch's British newspaper arm. The claimants' insurance policy covered ยฃ16 million of Associated's reported ยฃ34.5 million legal bill, indicating a significant shortfall.
the Daily Mail had made Meghanโs life โan absolute miseryโ
Originally published by Kathmandu Post in English. Translated, summarized, and contextualized by our editorial team with added local perspective. Read our editorial standards.