Pro-Israel Democrats battle to take on vulnerable Republican Rep. Mike Lawler

New York's 17th Congressional District, a suburban area near New York City with a significant Orthodox Jewish population, is holding a Democratic primary to select a challenger for Republican Rep. Mike Lawler. The race features Cait Conley, a military veteran and former national security adviser, and Beth Davidson, a member of the Rockland County Legislature.

Conley appears to hold a lead in recent polls and prediction markets over Davidson. Both candidates are addressing key voter concerns such as the cost of living, housing, and healthcare, while also seeking to win back moderate voters who previously supported Lawler. Lawler, known for his strong pro-Israel stance and close ties with Orthodox Jewish constituents, represents a significant challenge for the Democratic nominee.

Conley and Davidson both express support for the U.S.-Israel alliance but oppose certain actions by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government. They have also distanced themselves from Senate Democrats' efforts to block military sales to Israel. Davidson emphasizes her Jewish identity and values, such as tikkun olam, in her public service, while Conley highlights her national security background and supports a two-state solution.

Effie Phillips-Staley, a progressive candidate, is polling significantly behind Conley and Davidson. She has characterized Israel as an apartheid state committing genocide in Gaza. Lawler, despite not being Jewish, has cultivated a strong pro-Israel image, even facing criticism from William Paul, son of Sen. Rand Paul, for his alignment with the Jewish community.

“

Jews that have felt lost in the Democratic party.