DistantNews
Support us
Slashed pay, soaring workloads: AI didn’t take these Hongkongers’ jobs - but it hasn’t made them easier

Slashed pay, soaring workloads: AI didn’t take these Hongkongers’ jobs - but it hasn’t made them easier

From Hong Kong Free Press · () English

Summarized and contextualized by DistantNews.

At a glance

In-depth Named sources Context piece
  • Freelance translators in Hong Kong are experiencing significantly reduced pay and increased workloads due to AI-generated content.
  • While AI has not fully replaced human translators, it has transformed the industry, leading to lower rates and faster turnaround expectations.
  • This shift impacts the quality of work and the financial stability of translators, with some seeing pay cuts of up to 70%.

The rise of artificial intelligence is reshaping the landscape for freelance translators in Hong Kong, leading to drastically reduced pay and intensified workloads. While AI has not entirely eliminated human roles, it has fundamentally altered the industry, pushing for faster turnaround times and accepting lower compensation for tasks like editing and rewriting AI-generated subtitles.

Freelance translator Kelly Ng shared her experience, noting that she now edits and rewrites two TV episodes' worth of AI-generated subtitles in a single day for half the pay she received three years ago. This shift to "machine translation post-editing" has resulted in a significant pay cut, with one company dropping rates from HK$30 per minute of sitcom dialogue to as low as HK$9, a 70% reduction.

You won’t be getting the Gayle treatment in my post-winning Oprah lifestyle.

— Kelly NgA subtitle file on her laptop, illustrating the need to adapt cultural references for a local Hong Kong audience, highlighting the nuances AI may miss.

Research suggests that AI will "reshape more jobs than it replaces," with a significant portion of jobs expected to change substantially rather than disappear entirely. However, these transformations are not necessarily benefiting workers. Louiszen Yip, a system designer, has seen his workload quadruple due to AI coding tools, leading to sky-high expectations for efficiency while pay remains stagnant.

Manual subtitling jobs have become scarce as streaming platforms and translation agencies increasingly rely on AI-generated drafts. This evolving environment presents a challenging future for translators, who face pressure to adapt to new technologies while grappling with diminished earnings and increased demands on their time and expertise.

The rate

— Kelly NgReferring to the significantly reduced pay rates for translation work due to AI.
DistantNews Editorial

Originally published by Hong Kong Free Press. Summarized and contextualized by our editorial team with added local perspective. Read our editorial standards.