South Korean firm wins trademark battle against Monster Energy

A domestic South Korean beverage company has emerged victorious in a protracted trademark battle against the American energy drink powerhouse, Monster Energy. The legal dispute revolved around the distinctive claw-like markings featured on the packaging of both companies' products.

The Supreme Court's Second Division ruled in favor of the South Korean firm, J-Bio, upholding a lower court's decision. The case began in 2020 when J-Bio filed a petition with the Intellectual Property Tribunal, arguing that its "Health Booster" energy drink's packaging design did not infringe on Monster Energy's registered trademark.

While the Intellectual Property Tribunal initially sided with Monster Energy, deeming the claw designs similar enough to cause confusion, the Patent Court overturned this decision. The court differentiated the designs, stating that Monster Energy's logo, composed of three parallel lines, resembles a stylized 'm' suggestive of monster claws. In contrast, J-Bio's product features diagonal lines that appear more like simple scratches and are less likely to be perceived as an 'm'.

The court further noted differences in the text design, describing Monster Energy's font as rough and uneven, while J-Bio used a simpler gothic typeface. Ultimately, the Supreme Court concluded that the two trademarks are not similar enough to warrant a finding of infringement, allowing J-Bio to continue using its packaging design.

“

The two trademarks are not similar enough, so the plaintiff's product does not fall within the scope of Monster Energy's trademark rights.