South Korean Supreme Court Enhances Support for Judges Facing Lawsuits

In a significant move to bolster judicial independence and protect its personnel, the Supreme Court of Korea has implemented a comprehensive support system for judges facing legal challenges, particularly those accused under the recently introduced "law distortion crime" (beop-waegok-joe). This initiative includes the establishment of a dedicated "Judicial Litigation Support Center" within the Court Administration and a substantial increase in financial aid for legal defense.

The new regulations significantly expand the scope and amount of financial support for judges. Previously limited to a maximum of 5 million won for legal fees during the investigation phase, the support now extends to 10 million won before indictment and up to 20 million won per instance (심급) after indictment. This financial backing is crucial, especially given the surge in accusations, with 242 judges reportedly having been accused under the "law distortion crime" since its introduction in March. However, the system includes a provision requiring repayment of the support if a judge is ultimately found guilty, ensuring accountability.

“

In recent times, as unreasonable external burdens such as indiscriminate lawsuits and baseless personal attacks against judges and court officials have increased, there has been a growing concern that the essential function of the judiciary, which adjudicates independently according to law and conscience to protect the freedom and rights of the people, is being weakened.

The Court Administration stated that this measure is a response to the "unprecedented increase in unreasonable external burdens" such as "indiscriminate lawsuits and baseless personal attacks" against judges and court officials. They emphasized the need to create a work environment where judges can perform their duties without fear of reprisal, thereby safeguarding the "essential function of the judiciary as the last bastion protecting the fundamental rights of the people."

From our perspective at Hankyoreh, this judicial support system addresses a legitimate concern about protecting judges from potentially politically motivated or frivolous lawsuits. The "law distortion crime" itself has raised concerns among legal experts about its potential to infringe upon judicial independence. While ensuring judges can operate freely is paramount, the significant financial support and the sheer number of accusations warrant careful observation. This story is particularly relevant to us and our readers in South Korea because it touches upon the core principles of our justice system. It's not merely an administrative change; it's about the perceived vulnerability of judges and the state's response to protect them, which has implications for public trust in the judiciary. We must ensure that such support mechanisms do not inadvertently shield judges from genuine accountability while simultaneously protecting them from undue pressure.

“

The scope of support for lawyers' fees, which was previously limited to a maximum of 5 million won only during the investigation stage, has been revised to allow for up to 10 million won before indictment and up to 20 million won per instance after indictment.