Starter homes out of reach for most US prospective buyers, analysis finds

Buying a first home remains a distant dream for many Americans, with a recent LendingTree analysis showing that less than 40% of households without a home can afford a typical starter property. These entry-level homes, valued at the 25th percentile of the market and costing around $200,000, are crucial for building equity but are increasingly out of reach.

The income gap is a significant barrier. Non-homeowners need to earn just over $62,000 annually to afford a starter home, yet their median salary stands at $55,000. This $7,000 deficit, approximately 13%, presents a substantial hurdle. "Bridging that gap might require a side hustle, a second job or other sacrifices," noted Matt Schulz, LendingTree's chief consumer finance analyst, highlighting the difficulty for individuals already managing numerous demands.

“

It's safe to say that most people don't get raises of $7,099 each year. That means that bridging that gap might require a side hustle, a second job or other sacrifices. That's tough, however, especially with how many other demands people already have on their time.

The situation is particularly dire in states like California, where the median non-homeowner household earns $72,900 but falls short by $67,776 compared to the $140,676 needed for an average starter home costing $482,000. Schulz lamented, "For so many, it feels completely out of reach." He emphasized that homeownership is a powerful tool for wealth building and family stability, but the daunting financial figures deter many potential buyers.

In contrast, some Southern states present a more accessible entry point into homeownership. Mississippi leads with nearly 62% of households able to afford a starter home, followed by West Virginia (58%), Arkansas (54%), and Alabama (54%). These regions offer a more optimistic outlook for aspiring homeowners compared to the least affordable states like Rhode Island, Utah, and Hawaii, where affordability hovers at critically low percentages.

“

For so many, it feels completely out of reach. It's a shame because homeownership can be a powerful wealth-building tool and a real stabilizing force for families. However, the numbers involved are so daunting that many people don't see a realistic way to get into the market.