Takeaways from the NY primaries: Shifting Jewish power centers, Mamdani the Kingmaker and more

New York's Democratic primaries revealed a significant shift toward the party's progressive wing, with candidates endorsed by Mayor Zohran Mamdani securing key victories. These wins, particularly against two pro-Israel incumbents, have intensified discussions about the Democratic Party's stance on Israel and its relationship with the Jewish community.

“

Last night’s primaries indicate that DSA, Mamdani-backed candidates can win in different areas of New York City. But I don’t think that those same candidates could win anywhere else.

One of the notable outcomes was the victory of Brad Lander, who identifies as a liberal Zionist, over incumbent Rep. Dan Goldman. Lander's platform, which includes calls to end aid to Israeli defense systems like the Iron Dome, has drawn criticism from pro-Israel groups. Halie Soifer, CEO of the Jewish Democratic Council of America, suggested that while such candidates might win in specific New York City districts, their broader appeal is questionable. She also noted that Jewish voters often feel conflicted about Israel's role in Democratic politics.

“

We know that Jewish voters feel very conflicted about the issue of Israel and the role that it’s now playing in Democratic politics.

Other Jewish leaders expressed alarm over the rhetoric used by some public figures. Rabbi Jonah Pesner of the Reform Judaism's Religious Action Center stated his concern about leaders who "vilify Jews and others who support Israel." He rejected the idea of a "false choice between Jewish safety and Palestinian dignity" and vowed to oppose those whose words or actions undermine Jewish safety or deny Israel's right to exist.

“

We are deeply concerned by public leaders who vilify Jews and others who support Israel, including many who also strive for peace, support Palestinian rights, and mourn the suffering of innocent civilians.

The primaries highlight a complex and evolving political dynamic within New York's Jewish community, with establishment figures and progressive Jewish voices navigating differing views on Israel and its place in American politics.

“

We reject the false choice between Jewish safety and Palestinian dignity. We will work with leaders across political and ideological lines when they share our values, and we will speak out forcefully when their words or actions undermine Jewish safety, demonize supporters of Israel, or deny Israel’s right to exist and thrive in security.