Taoyuan Wind Music Carnival Held in Rain Sparks Controversy; City Government Defends Decision

Taoyuan City's Department of Information Director, Luo Chudong, has strongly refuted criticism from Democratic Progressive Party councilor Huang Qionghui regarding an outdoor concert held in the rain. Huang had questioned the quality of the performance, expressing concern for the musicians, particularly the conductor who was drenched, and the use of plastic coverings on instruments. She also criticized officials in the audience for smiling during the downpour.

“

The conductor was drenched, and the instruments were even covered in plastic... I felt sorry seeing it. How could the officials sitting in the audience still smile!

Luo countered by drawing a parallel to a 2021 music festival during the previous administration, also held in the rain. He noted that such events were then widely praised for the performers' professionalism and dedication. Luo questioned why a similar scene, which was previously seen as a moving display of artistic passion, is now being labeled as "not demanding quality" and "just holding the event." He provocatively asked if Huang would have similarly criticized officials, including former Mayor Cheng Wen-tsan, if they had smiled during that earlier rain-soaked performance.

“

In 2021, during the previous mayor's term, the wind music carnival also started in the rain, and the performance team's professionalism and persistence were widely praised.

The city government emphasized that the decision to continue the performance was made after thorough discussions between the organizers and the Tokyo Kosei Wind Orchestra. Luo stated that relevant contingency measures were implemented at the venue. He expressed high respect and gratitude for the orchestra's professionalism and dedication, as well as for the audience's understanding. The Taoyuan City Government affirmed its commitment to continuous review and improvement to ensure the annual Taoyuan Wind Music Carnival remains a highly anticipated cultural event for its citizens.

“

For the same rainy scene, because the mayor is different, it is criticized as worthless.