The hard state

Punjab's government has introduced a new bill designed to combat habitual offenders and curb anti-social conduct that undermines state authority and public order. This proposed legislation seeks to replace two older laws: the pre-independence Restriction of Habitual Offenders Act of 1918 and the Punjab Control of Goondas Ordinance from 1959.

Officials state the new bill is a modern alternative to deter deviant and anti-social behavior, acknowledging that the previous laws have become ineffective. The move signifies an effort to update the legal framework for maintaining public safety and order within the province.

“

to provide for control of habitual offenders and anti-social behaviour that affect the writ of state, cause public nuisance and expose society to criminal activities

However, the bill has drawn criticism for its potential to be misused. Concerns have been raised that the legislation embodies a 'hard state' approach, potentially enabling the government to suppress dissent through stringent legal measures. Section 6 of the bill, in particular, has been flagged for its controversial definitions of 'anti-social behavior,' fueling fears of its application against political opposition.

“

Such laws help unpopular governments curb dissent through draconian legislation.