Trump's 'low-key' Iran talks claim reignites US policy debate

President Donald Trump's recent announcement that Washington intends to "low-key" its approach to Iran has once again sparked debate surrounding the White House's shifting policy toward the Islamic Republic.

“

I’ve stopped being worried or getting excited about Trump’s statements. Tomorrow it could be different, and the day after tomorrow he could change course again. Tomorrow he could declare war, and three days later announce a deal, and next week it could flip again.

Suleiman Maswadeh, a commentator for Israel's Channel 13 News, expressed skepticism about the predictability of Trump's stance. Speaking on 103FM, Maswadeh cautioned that such statements do not necessarily indicate future direction, highlighting the president's tendency to change course. "Tomorrow it could be different, and the day after tomorrow he could change course again," Maswadeh said, suggesting a potential for drastic shifts from declaring war to announcing a deal.

“

From day one, we talked about how the midterm elections were problematic and troubling elections. The midterms are only in November. I think Trump is currently pleased with the economic siege imposed on Iran and the damage it is doing to their economy.

Maswadeh believes domestic politics, particularly the upcoming November midterm elections, significantly influences Trump's decisions. He noted that Trump appears pleased with the economic pressure on Iran, which is damaging its economy. However, Maswadeh questioned how Israel would view this situation, suggesting that while the Iranian people suffer, the Revolutionary Guards might grow stronger.

“

I don’t know how pleased Israel will be with this, but when the Iranian people are hungry and reduced to living on bread alone, the Revolutionary Guards will grow stronger. Trump has chosen a side. I don’t want to say the side of the Arab states, but that’s the situation.

The commentator also pointed to a perceived gap between initial negotiation aspirations and the current reality. He described the situation as a "fiasco," noting that talks have devolved from a memorandum of understanding towards a comprehensive agreement to discussions about an agreement that falls below the MOU's level, and is not even directly between the US and Iran. Despite current reassurances from Washington, Maswadeh warned that the possibility of escalation remains due to Trump's unpredictable nature and provocative statements from Tehran.

“

Look at the fiasco. We were at the memorandum of understanding, which was supposed to be the path toward a comprehensive agreement. Now we’re talking about an agreement that is actually below the level of the memorandum of understanding, and it isn’t even between the United States and Iran. It’s between Oman and Iran - and even that still isn’t happening.