20% Expert Meeting Minutes Released; Food Safety Official Warns of Wider Recall Impact

Minutes from a 20% expert meeting concerning the Zhonglian Oils case have been publicly released by Taiwan's Food and Drug Administration, shedding light on the decision-making process behind product recalls. The released 17-page document details discussions where Xu Fu, director of the Executive Yuan's Office of Food Safety, expressed reservations about the extent of the recall.

During the meeting, Xu Fu cautioned that a directive for a comprehensive recall of second-tier processed products could inadvertently affect third and fourth-tier products. This statement highlights the complex supply chain considerations involved in food safety incidents and the potential ripple effects of regulatory actions. The minutes also list the names of participating experts and company representatives, including Su Nan-wei, Chen Bing-hui, Qiu Hui-wen, Zhu Yan-hua, Dong Zhi-hong, Yang Deng-jie, Yan Guo-qin, and from Zhonglian Oils, General Manager Yu Ling-chong, Plant Manager Chen Ming-rong, and R&D Section Chief Chen Jian-long.

Earlier in the meeting, experts identified the frequency of raw material testing by the company as a potential primary cause of the incident. Following discussions on Zhonglian Oils' production processes, the chairman, Jiang Zhi-gang, inquired about the necessity of a full recall for blended oils from second-tier manufacturers. Xu Fu's subsequent remarks about the cascading impact on lower-tier products underscored the challenges in containment.

Following Xu Fu's statement, Expert A suggested narrowing the scope of the recall to "packaged foods with more than 20% of problematic oil content" for precautionary measures. Expert E voiced concerns about this approach, noting it did not account for varying consumption levels of different products. Expert F supported the idea, believing it would effectively mitigate risks and suggested prioritizing larger businesses for easier management. Ultimately, Jiang Zhi-gang announced the conclusion: second-tier businesses were instructed to self-assess. If their products contained over 20% of the problematic oil or were blended oils still in their original form, a precautionary recall was mandated.

“

If we require second-tier processed products to be fully recalled, it will also involve third and fourth-tier products.