Adalah petitions High Court to return bodies of six Arab citizens withheld by Israel

The Palestinian legal aid group Adalah has taken a significant step by petitioning Israel's High Court of Justice, demanding the immediate return of the bodies of six Arab citizens held by the state for extended periods. This legal challenge directly confronts the state's longstanding policy of withholding bodies, a practice previously justified as leverage in negotiations for Israeli captives. Adalah argues that this rationale has collapsed following the return of all living and slain Israeli hostages over the past six months, rendering the continued detention of these bodies unlawful and disproportionate.

“

The purpose that formed the basis for the decision to hold the bodies no longer exists.

Adalah attorney Salam Irsheid, filing the petition on behalf of the families, emphasizes that the state's justification for withholding the bodies is no longer tenable. The petition contends that the "total change in circumstances" following a deal between Israel and Hamas has fundamentally altered the legal and strategic landscape. Cabinet decisions that underpinned this policy are now irrelevant, and the state cannot continue to justify the retention of these bodies without proper authority or a compelling, current security need.

“

The current filing argues that those rulings were contingent on a factual and strategic reality that has since shifted.

Framing the issue as a constitutional violation, Adalah asserts that the right to a dignified burial is an integral part of the constitutional right to human dignity under Israeli law. The ongoing withholding of these bodies constitutes a "severe and continuous" violation of the dignity of both the deceased and their families. This legal action highlights the deep-seated grievances and the pursuit of justice for families who have endured prolonged suffering, seeking not only the return of their loved ones but also a fundamental recognition of their rights and dignity.

“

The right to a dignified burial, it argues, is an integral part of the constitutional right to human dignity, protected under Israeli law.