Alfaro Sparks Debate on Paraguayan National Team's Identity After Germany Upset

Gustavo Alfaro has silenced his critics after leading Paraguay to a historic victory over Germany in the 2026 World Cup Round of 16. This triumph has ignited a debate within Paraguayan football circles about the national team's identity and the type of playing style it should adopt moving forward.

Paraguayan football is traditionally known for its "garra guaraní," a combative spirit, and a straightforward "formula" often involving crosses to a tall center-forward. However, in this World Cup, Paraguay has displayed a range of tactical approaches under Alfaro, sometimes deviating from their characteristic grit and traditional style. The team experienced a significant loss to the United States in the group stage but recovered with a win against Turkey, despite a red card, and secured a draw against Australia to advance.

“

He is a character who knows nothing about football. All he knows how to do is talk.

Alfaro himself has acknowledged the debate, noting that it's unusual for Paraguayans not to celebrate advancing in the World Cup. He has also engaged in a public exchange with former goalkeeper José Luis Chilavert, who had been critical of Alfaro's coaching. Chilavert called Alfaro a "character who knows nothing about football" and accused him of merely talking. Alfaro, in turn, labeled Chilavert a "sniper" and questioned why Paraguayans weren't happier about their World Cup progression.

The controversy surrounding Alfaro's methods and Paraguay's playing style has been amplified by their unexpected success. After defeating Germany on penalties following a defensive and combative performance, the criticism has largely subsided, replaced by a focus on preparation for their upcoming match against France. Alfaro's decision to open this discussion about the team's future direction has added another layer to Paraguay's World Cup journey.

“

The World Cup is high-level football and not a congress of 'Corrupbol' (Conmebol), where you are the philosopher of the moment. Stop lying to the Paraguayan people.