Book on Norwegian publishing industry criticized for excessive nostalgia

A recent portrait of the Norwegian publishing industry, authored by Knut Gørvell, is drawing criticism for its overwhelming focus on nostalgia. Reviewers suggest the book is so steeped in reminiscence that it inadvertently fosters sympathy for those who might be seen as antagonists to the industry's traditional structures.

The critique, published in Aftenposten, implies that Gørvell's deep dive into the past of Norwegian publishing, while perhaps intended as a celebration of its heritage, ultimately detracts from a more critical or forward-looking examination. This nostalgic lens, the review argues, might lead readers to empathize with figures or forces that have historically challenged or opposed the established publishing houses.

This perspective suggests that the book's strength, its detailed historical account, may also be its weakness. By dwelling on bygone eras and sentiments, the work risks presenting a romanticized view that overlooks the complexities and challenges facing the industry today. The review implies a missed opportunity to engage with the present through a more balanced or contemporary narrative.