Brazilian Supreme Court Justices Clash Over Detention of Banker's Relatives

A division has emerged within Brazil's Supreme Court's Second Panel regarding the ongoing detention of Felipe Cançado Vorcaro and his father, Henrique Moura Vorcaro, who are implicated in "Operation Compliance Zero." The case centers on measures determined in May against the defendants, including the banker Daniel Vorcaro's relatives.

“

When an agreement is made in an environment of pressure, there is a complete erosion of the voluntariness that must necessarily guide any collaboration.

Justice Gilmar Mendes, who had previously requested more information on the case, argued on Tuesday for the father's transfer to house arrest with an electronic monitoring tag, and for the cousin's release. Mendes suggested that preventive detention could be used as a tactic to pressure the individuals into plea bargain agreements, drawing a parallel to methods employed in the "Lava Jato" (Car Wash) operation. He also highlighted what he perceives as violations of the Vorcaros' rights, stating, "The investigated individuals are people who have made some kind of mistake, but that does not strip them of their rights."

“

The investigated individuals are people who have made some kind of mistake, but that does not strip them of their rights.

Conversely, Justice André Mendonça, the rapporteur for Operation Compliance Zero, defended the continuation of the precautionary measures. He pointed to evidence of violent conduct by a group acting under Vorcaro's orders, asserting, "We are not talking about Lava Jato, Minister Gilmar," and emphasizing that this case involves actions akin to those of the mafia, including death threats.

“

We are not talking about Lava Jato, Minister Gilmar.

Felipe Vorcaro is considered by the Federal Police to be part of the financial and operational core of the criminal group led by the banker. Henrique Vorcaro allegedly coordinated a group known as "A Turma" (The Gang), which organized intimidation tactics against the banker's adversaries. The Federal Police report that these activities continued even after the task force investigating illicit activities related to Banco Master was formed. Henrique Vorcaro, as president of Multipar, was also involved in transactions totaling over R$1 billion between 2020 and 2025, which the Council for Financial Activities Control (Coaf) suggests were attempts to conceal assets.

“

This case involves mafia-like actions because it even includes death threats to people.