Caution urged over potential e-scooter ban

Calls for caution are being voiced by politicians and commuter groups concerning a potential outright ban on electric scooters in public spaces. This comes after the Taoiseach expressed a leaning towards a complete ban earlier this week, a stance also supported by Garda Commissioner Justin Kelly. Concerns have been amplified by a report from Children's Health Ireland highlighting traumatic brain injuries sustained by young e-scooter users.

“

Our position is that the Government needs to look at properly enforcing the existing legislation that they have in place before they start talking about an outright ban.

However, questions are being raised about the enforcement of current legislation. Josh Ellul, a member of the Dublin Commuter Coalition, described an outright ban as a "blunt force instrument." He argued that the government should focus on enforcing existing laws before contemplating a ban, suggesting that a ban might not effectively address the illegal use of e-scooters.

“

An outright ban is a blunt force instrument that is probably not going to actually effectively tackle the illegal use of e-scooters that we're seeing.

Green Party representative Roderic O'Gorman also urged restraint, stating he does not support a full ban. He believes a ban would be ineffective and unfairly penalize the thousands who rely on e-scooters for daily commutes. Fianna Fáil TD Shane Moynihan proposed focusing on a revised regulatory framework, including registration, licensing, and insurance requirements, to ensure traceability and enforce the existing ban on riders under 16. He emphasized the need for enforcement, education, and proactive community policing.

“

I don't support a full ban on e-scooters. I don't think it'll work, but more importantly, I think it's going to unfairly punish the thousands of people who use a e-scooter every single day to get to and from work.

The discussion around e-scooter use is expected to intensify when the Dáil reconvenes after its summer recess in September.

“

I think we need to look at the regulatory framework around e-scooters. I've been calling for some time now for a registration, licensing, insuring requirements, so these vehicles are traceable and we can enforce then the under-16 ban that exists already. But this isn't just about a regulatory framework. It's about enforcement. It's about education, and it's about proactive community policing as well.