Commentary: Surrogacy and the Catholic Church – A person must never be a means to an end

The Catholic Church maintains a firm stance against surrogacy, viewing it as an affront to human dignity. The core of this objection lies in the principle that a person should never be treated as a mere instrument to fulfill another's desires. The church argues that the legitimate wish to have a child cannot be elevated to an absolute right that justifies such practices.

From the church's theological perspective, surrogacy commodifies human life and relationships. It suggests that the process can lead to the exploitation of women, particularly those in vulnerable economic situations, who may be coerced into carrying a child for others. Furthermore, it raises complex questions about the identity and rights of the child born through surrogacy, as well as the nature of the parent-child bond.

“

The legitimate desire to have a child cannot be transformed into a right to a child.

The church's position is rooted in its understanding of the sanctity of life and the traditional family structure. It advocates for alternative paths to parenthood, such as adoption, that align with its moral teachings. The commentary emphasizes that while the desire for a child is understandable, it must be pursued through means that uphold the inherent worth and dignity of all individuals involved.

“

A human being must never be a means to an end.