Constitutional Court weighs messenger surveillance challenge

Austria's Constitutional Court is weighing a challenge to government surveillance of messenger services, a law the opposition argues infringes on fundamental rights. The case pits the government's need to prevent terrorism against privacy concerns, echoing a previous legal battle.

“

I ask you to remain in your seats despite the warm temperatures.

The opposition, represented by FPÖ and Green party members, argues that the current law is a mere modification of a previous surveillance measure that the court struck down in 2019. They contend that the software used for surveillance cannot selectively read messenger data but instead accesses all phone data, constituting an overreach.

“

I had a déjà vu.

Lawyers for the opposition also raised concerns about the state purchasing surveillance software that exploits security vulnerabilities. They questioned the security of this data, fearing it could be compromised or fall into the hands of the software provider. The government, however, maintains that the measure is "essential and unavoidable" for combating terrorism and that the software will be tailored to specific needs, not a blanket solution.

“

But in substance, that changes nothing.