Employer Cannot Challenge Occupational Disease Ruling: Important Court Verdict

In Poland, the principle of protecting employee health and safety in the workplace is paramount, and this recent ruling by the Supreme Administrative Court (Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny) strongly reaffirms that position. The case, concerning an employee suffering from carpal tunnel syndrome due to years of repetitive tasks in electrical harness production, highlights a critical aspect of labor law: the weight given to expert medical opinions.

“

If the medical assessment issued by an authorized medical unit does not raise fundamental doubts, it constitutes the primary evidence allowing for the diagnosis of an occupational disease.

The employer's attempt to dispute the occupational disease diagnosis, despite initial findings by the State Sanitary Inspection and a lower court's affirmation, was ultimately unsuccessful. The Supreme Administrative Court's decision emphasizes that when a medical assessment from an authorized institution is sound, it serves as the primary evidence for diagnosing an occupational disease. Administrative bodies, lacking specialized medical knowledge, are not equipped to question these findings.

“

Administrative bodies are not authorized to challenge its findings based on their own assessment, which lacks specialized knowledge.

This verdict is significant for workers in Poland, particularly those in physically demanding roles. It provides a clear legal precedent that employers cannot easily dismiss medical evidence of work-related illnesses. The ruling underscores the importance of specialized medical knowledge in determining occupational diseases and reinforces the legal protections afforded to employees in Poland, ensuring that their health concerns are taken seriously and are legally recognized when supported by expert medical opinion.

“

Medical assessments regarding occupational diseases are considered evidence based on specialized knowledge.