DistantNews
Support us
FIFA faces 'dictatorship' accusations over controversial World Cup penalty
๐Ÿ‡ฑ๐Ÿ‡น Lithuania /Sports

FIFA faces 'dictatorship' accusations over controversial World Cup penalty

From Delfi · () Lithuanian

Translated from Lithuanian, summarized and contextualized by DistantNews.

At a glance

News Named sources Outcome reported
  • FIFA and football legends criticized a controversial penalty awarded in a World Cup match between Switzerland and Qatar.
  • The penalty, scored by Breel Embolo, was awarded after Remo Freuler collided with the Qatari goalkeeper, but replays suggested Freuler may have been offside.
  • FIFA cited a "system error and short technical failure" for the inability to show replays, drawing accusations of a "dictatorship" from critics demanding transparency.

A controversial penalty awarded in a World Cup match between Switzerland and Qatar has sparked outrage among football fans and legends, with FIFA facing accusations of a lack of transparency.

Everyone sitting here and the viewers at home think that the goal was scored from offside. FIFA is the host, they have the automated decision evidence, so why don't they show it to us?

โ€” Gary NevilleCriticizing FIFA's handling of the VAR review and demanding transparency.

The incident occurred in the 14th minute when Swiss midfielder Remo Freuler collided with Qatari goalkeeper Mahmoud Abunada. The referee awarded a penalty, which Breel Embolo converted, giving Switzerland a 1-0 lead. However, television replays appeared to show Freuler was in an offside position before the collision, leading to widespread questioning of the decision.

During the match, a Video Assistant Referee (VAR) review was conducted, but the referee's decision stood. This lack of clarity and the subsequent withholding of detailed replays by FIFA drew sharp criticism. Former England player and Manchester United legend Gary Neville likened FIFA's actions to an authoritarian regime, demanding transparency. "They have these proofs, but they don't show them to the fans," Neville stated, questioning the lack of transparency. Fellow legend Ian Wright echoed these sentiments, calling the situation "scandalous."

It's like a dictatorship in the sense that they have these proofs, but they don't show them to the fans. It's just ridiculous, so prove to us that it's not offside, because where is the transparency now?

โ€” Gary NevilleAccusing FIFA of authoritarian behavior due to the lack of evidence sharing.

FIFA later issued a statement attributing the inability to show animated replays to a "system error and short technical failure." They claimed this did not affect the referees' final verdict. FIFA also released images on social media showing VAR lines, purportedly proving that neither Freuler nor Embolo were offside. However, the promised 3D graphics were not made public, leaving many fans and critics unsatisfied and fueling further distrust.

They do what they want, and we see it now, because it is scandalous.

โ€” Ian WrightExpressing disappointment and calling the situation scandalous.
DistantNews Editorial

Originally published by Delfi in Lithuanian. Translated, summarized, and contextualized by our editorial team with added local perspective. Read our editorial standards.

More Stories

From Our Blog