France divided over air conditioning amid record heatwave

France is grappling with a political divide over air conditioning as the nation endures a severe heatwave, marked by the hottest night on record since 1947. The debate pits those who view air conditioning as a necessary tool against those who see it as a detrimental environmental and energy issue.

“

It is absurd to let people die of heat.

Jean-Luc Mélenchon's La France Insoumise (LFI) party leads the opposition to widespread air conditioning. They argue that the devices consume significant energy and release heat into public spaces, intensifying the urban heat island effect. LFI advocates for alternative solutions like enhanced building insulation and the development of public cooling networks, which use chilled water circulated through pipes, often sourced from nearby rivers.

Conversely, the far-right National Rally (RN), led by Marine Le Pen, proposes a massive expansion of air conditioning. Their plan includes installing 20 million new units across France, specifically targeting schools, public hospitals, and nursing homes, where current cooling is insufficient. Le Pen expressed outrage at the idea of people suffering from heat, stating, "It is absurd to let people die of heat."

“

temporary response

Even in Paris, where the urban heat effect is most pronounced, the city's socialist mayor, Emmanuel Gregoire, has announced the installation of 1,200 air conditioning units in approximately 600 schools. While acknowledging this as a "temporary response" and maintaining a principled opposition to air conditioning, Gregoire's decision reflects a pragmatic shift. Similarly, the Green party leader, Marine Tondelier, has conceded that air conditioning is "essential" in certain situations, highlighting the complex trade-offs France faces in adapting to extreme heat.

“

essential