Froyo vs. Ice Cream: Which is Healthier According to Nutritionists?

Frozen yogurt, or froyo, enjoys a reputation for being a healthier alternative to ice cream, often promoted as low-fat and probiotic-rich. However, nutrition experts suggest this distinction isn't always clear-cut, and the perceived health benefits might be influenced by marketing.

Johannah Katz, a registered dietitian, explains that ice cream is made from pasteurized, sweetened cream and milk, then frozen and processed for a smooth texture. Regulations often mandate a minimum of 10% milk fat. Froyo, on the other hand, uses a fermented yogurt base, which naturally results in lower lactose content compared to traditional ice cream.

“

Ice cream is made from a mixture of pasteurized, sweetened cream and milk, frozen, then processed to a smooth texture.

Despite froyo's lower saturated fat content, registered dietitian Megan Wroe points out that it frequently contains higher amounts of added sugar. "The original taste of yogurt tends to be sour. To mask this sourness and make it appealing to the public, producers usually add more sugar," Wroe explains. Ice cream, while higher in calories and saturated fat, may have relatively less added sugar.

“

The original taste of yogurt tends to be sour. To mask this sourness and make it appealing to the public, producers usually add more sugar.

Toppings present another significant factor. Many self-serve froyo shops allow customers to add their own toppings, which can quickly escalate the calorie count. What starts as a low-fat froyo can become a calorie bomb with additions like brownies, cookies, sweet sauces, or candy. Katz also cautions that while froyo contains live cultures, the number of active beneficial bacteria can decrease significantly by the time it's consumed in its frozen state.

Ultimately, the choice between froyo and ice cream depends on personal dietary needs. Froyo might be preferable for individuals with mild lactose intolerance or those aiming to reduce saturated fat intake, provided they choose healthier toppings like fresh fruit or nuts. Ice cream could be a better choice for those seeking a more sustained feeling of fullness due to its higher fat content. Both desserts can be enjoyed in moderation, with mindful selection of additions.

“

While made from live cultures, the amount of active beneficial bacteria remaining when froyo is consumed in a frozen state can be significantly reduced.