DistantNews
Support us
"I Hear What You're Saying" Is on Psychologists' Blacklist. So Are Some Other Words.
๐Ÿ‡ณ๐Ÿ‡ด Norway /Culture & Society

"I Hear What You're Saying" Is on Psychologists' Blacklist. So Are Some Other Words.

From Aftenposten · () Norwegian

Translated from Norwegian, summarized and contextualized by DistantNews.

At a glance

News Sources not specified Context piece
  • Psychologists advise against immediately dismissing negative self-talk from children or friends, such as calling themselves "stupid" or "a failure."
  • Instead, they recommend starting by understanding the person's experience to potentially change the conversation.
  • This approach is highlighted as a way to foster more constructive dialogue when someone expresses self-doubt.

When a friend laments a failed date or a child declares they "don't understand anything" and are "so stupid," the instinct is often to immediately reassure them. Phrases like "You'll find someone" or "You just need to practice more" are common responses.

However, psychologists suggest a different approach. Psychologist Elizabeth Malmquist advises, "Start by understanding the experience. It can change the conversation." This method emphasizes validating the person's feelings rather than immediately countering their negative self-assessment.

The idea is that by first acknowledging and seeking to understand the individual's perspective, one can create a more open and receptive environment for further discussion. This contrasts with the common tendency to quickly dismiss such statements, which can sometimes feel invalidating to the person expressing distress.

This approach, which includes phrases like "I hear what you're saying," is reportedly on psychologists' "blacklist" of unhelpful responses. The article suggests that shifting from immediate dismissal to empathetic understanding can be a more effective way to support someone struggling with self-criticism or feelings of inadequacy.

Start by understanding the experience. It can change the conversation.

โ€” Elizabeth MalmquistAdvising on a more empathetic approach to responding to negative self-talk.
DistantNews Editorial

Originally published by Aftenposten in Norwegian. Translated, summarized, and contextualized by our editorial team with added local perspective. Read our editorial standards.