DistantNews
Support us

Is China to Blame for the China-Nepal Border Disaster? Indian Host Leaves Chinese ‘Wolf Warrior’ Rattled

From Liberty Times · () Chinese

Translated from Chinese and summarized by DistantNews. Read the original for the full story.

At a glance

News Named sources Ongoing story
  • A glacial collapse and flash flood near the China-Nepal border reportedly killed at least 955 people and left nearly 4,500 missing by Aug. 31.
  • Indian host Arnab Goswami challenged Chinese commentator Gao Zhikai over allegations that development in Tibet worsened the disaster and that downstream countries lacked timely warnings.
  • The televised exchange also revived concerns over China’s ability to use rivers originating in Tibet as leverage against downstream states, according to remarks cited in the program.

A heated Indian television debate over a deadly flood on the China-Nepal border has gone viral after Chinese commentator Gao Zhikai clashed with host Arnab Goswami, known in Taiwan as the “Indian Pao Chieh.”

This is extremely cold-hearted. We are a downstream country, so this has a great deal to do with us. Hundreds of Indians have also died.

— Unnamed Indian guestThe guest rejected Gao Zhikai’s argument that India had no right to comment on the disaster.

The disaster began on Aug. 26 when a glacier on Nepal’s side of the Himalayas collapsed near Langtang Lirung. The falling ice shattered on impact and became a torrent more than 30 meters high, carrying meltwater, rocks and mud through a narrow valley. The flood crossed into China, struck the Lhende River and hit the Gyirong border port in Tibet before a landslide briefly blocked the river and created a barrier lake. The lake then burst under pressure, sending water back toward downstream Nepal along the Trishuli River and toward India’s border.

By Aug. 31, China and Nepal had confirmed at least 955 deaths and nearly 4,500 missing people. Citizens of both countries, as well as foreign tourists, were affected. India counted among the hardest-hit foreign groups, and parts of its border region also felt the impact.

I am about to say something that will completely expose him.

— Arnab GoswamiGoswami introduced his challenge to Gao over remarks allegedly made in Pakistan.

The program’s Indian guests argued that the disaster reflected both climate change and intensive development on the Chinese side of the Himalayas, including road and rail projects, power lines, hydropower stations, excavation and reservoir construction. They also criticized the lack of immediate cross-border warnings to Nepal and India, saying downstream communities had less chance to respond.

We will use our rivers, turn them into weapons, to attack and target India.

— Gao Zhikai, as quoted by Arnab GoswamiGoswami cited the alleged remark while arguing that Gao had threatened India through control of rivers originating in Tibet.

Gao rejected India’s involvement, arguing that only China and Nepal had the right to address the disaster because their territories directly bordered the affected area. Other guests called that position cold-hearted, pointing out that India was a downstream country and that hundreds of Indians had died. Goswami repeatedly stopped Gao from interrupting before confronting him over earlier remarks about turning rivers into weapons against India. Gao denied the host’s account, while Goswami accused him of making threats. The confrontation spread widely online.

But that is exactly what you are doing! How do I know you did not use water against the Nepalese? Because that is what you said in Pakistan, Gao Zhikai!

— Arnab GoswamiGoswami concluded the confrontation by accusing Gao of threatening downstream countries.
About this summary

Originally published by Liberty Times in Chinese. Translated, summarized, and contextualized automatically by DistantNews, with a note on how the source frames the story. Not individually reviewed before publishing. How this works.